Feb
2009
16

I hate what you say but I will defend to the last your right to say it

Our freedom of speech is an all important thing, especially in this day and age, but it seems that some groups want it to apply only to them and not to others.  You see this everywhere, between church and state, liberal and conservative, gay and straight, name two groups and I guarantee that they believe what they say is right and they would prefer that their opponents be silenced.  Sometimes what the opposition says is truly horrible but I would still believe in their right to say it.  In my life I go searching for articles and viewpoints that oppose mine.  I believe that only when you have both sides to an argument that you can truly make an informed decision.  This is not to say that I am swayed in reading the opposition but that I believe that knowledge of it is important.

My belief in these principles was reaffirmed by my last post on this blog and the many comments that were left on it.  One of the issues that came up was that there was a great disbelief that a lesbian could express views such as mine.  I get that, my beliefs fall more into the conservative world view in the general sense.  My life was obviously different, I grew up on a ranch fixing fences and shooting guns and I still to this day profess little desire to join the gay/lesbian community as a whole.  I certainly don’t hate the community just I don’t really need it in my life as of yet.  I don’t know if that makes sense but I’m still only 24 and readily admit to still forming/changing parts of my identity.  Maybe the community will be more important to me in later years, I don’t know.

I didn’t write the post with the intent to insult or offend, it was just my and my classmates opinion on Obama, gun rights and gay rights.  I honestly thought that people might be intrigued or interested in the train of thought but little else.  I don’t know, perhaps I labor under the illusion that everyone reads or listens to the other side of things.  Hell, I’ll read any one’s opinion.  Left wing, right wing, black separatist, white separatist, extremist and moderate views on religion, pro gay, anti gay, pro feminist, anti feminist, it don’t matter.  I believe in the validity of every one’s argument and in their ultimate right to say it.  I think that anyone who says that they, whoever they may be, has no right to say those things is a bigot.  And I mean bigot as in a bigot (in modern usage) is a prejudiced person who is intolerant of any opinions differing from their own.

My belief is that we should listen to the other side’s argument at least once, even if it is to only reaffirm our own beliefs and practices.  If we only ever eat, sleep and breathe our own conceptions then we have not truly done service to our own intelligence.  We have cheated ourselves of the whole story and in doing so we are one sided constructs unable to truly think as individuals.

Besides, I have known many, many people who’s views do not jive with my own.  I have had many an interesting and fulfilling conversation with such people and have walked away more knowledgeable.  Face it, God loves great variety and I think we as human beings should too.  Life would be pretty boring otherwise.

Share

I couldn’t agree with you more. I think that more people should look at both sides of an issue if only to educate themselves further on said issue.

by goldstardyke on February 16th, 2009 at 10:06 PM

Ya can’t have a coin without both sides.

by Tuzz on February 16th, 2009 at 11:34 PM

I agree. I do feel that people always thinks that they are right no mater what. I know plenty of people who are constantly always thinking they are right no matter what.

by Alexa Dagostino on February 17th, 2009 at 9:05 AM

You do have a right to speak your mind. And I applaud you for reading opposing points of view. It is important to question and research what is being said in order by all sides to find out the truth.

But remember that part of what you shared in your previous post is your opposition to gay rights. I believe it is this opposition to equal rights that has people riled up.

I too grew up in a very conservative part of the country. I used to be part of an ultra conservative church and believed the rhetoric they spouted. I didn’t question these beliefs because I lived in an environment that discouraged questioning, branding critical thinkers as heretics.

I felt as you did until I came out of the closet and was turned away from my church, abandoned by my family and fired from my job. I was beaten up repeatedly and raped for being gay. And those in the Republican Party encouraged the divisive and hateful attitudes towards people like me.

I encourage you to try an experiment. Wear a pride T-shirt to school. Tell your friends and family about your being gay. Announce it at your place of worship and at the next NRA meeting you attend. Ask for their support in living your life honestly.

If you truly believe that your community and your school and your political party and your gun-rights supporters are your friends, put it to the test. Find out the truth. And see who your true friends are.

I hope you’re right. I hope your community and your school don’t care whether you are gay or straight. I hope they aren’t tempted to abandon you or attack you. I certainly don’t want you hurt. But if finding the truth is important to you, it’s time to put your beliefs to the test.

Peace out,
Dharmashanti Kelleher

by Dharma Kelleher on February 17th, 2009 at 9:48 AM

Leave a Comment

Our Sponsors

GLBT Ad Hives

LesbianBloggers
The Lesbian Blogger Ad Hive is a varied group of blogs written by lesbians of diverse backgrounds and interests and containing lesbian interest stories.

Friends of TLL

Lesbian Videos at LesbianLoveNow


LDate.com - The best place in the world for lesbian singles!
LDate.com - The best place in the world for lesbian singles!

DFW BI NET is a social and support group for bisexual, bi-curious and bi-friendly people in North Texas.
Follow TLLBlog on Twitter